cannabisnews.com: Claims Against Marijuana Legislation are Distorted





Claims Against Marijuana Legislation are Distorted
Posted by FoM on March 19, 2000 at 21:54:00 PT
Letters To The Editor 
Source: Honolulu Advertiser
Dr. John T. McDonnell’s pronouncements on the pending medical marijuana legislation (Island Voices, Feb. 28) are so filled with misinformation and distortions that they demand rebuttal.The proposed legislation does not contravene federal laws against marijuana. It merely calls for the protection of bona fide patients and their doctors from arrest and prosecution by state and county authorities, who are neither expected nor required to enforce federal laws.
Furthermore, contrary to McDonnell’s claim, the proposed law does not allow sale or distribution of marijuana by anyone, including patients.McDonnell’s references to “prescribing” marijuana suggest that he has not even read the legislation that he denounces. Nowhere is the word “prescribe” used in the bill. Physicians may recommend, but not prescribe, mainly because there is no pharmacy that could fill those prescriptions.McDonnell stretches the truth when he claims that in the states that have passed similar legislation, doctors will not prescribe marijuana as medicine. Since none of the bills call for “prescription,” that is true. However, numerous doctors in the six states where medical marijuana is legal are recommending this natural herb as medicine in conditions that can be helped by it.When the doctor asserts that “we don’t really know” whether there are therapeutic uses of marijuana, he ignores a vast scientific literature on the subject, as well as more recent data compiled from personal experiences of thousands of patients. That the scientific studies are “decades old” is true, but only because the DEA has blocked all efforts to conduct studies since 1980. As a surgeon with more than 40 years of experience, I have recommended marijuana where appropriate and have seen its effectiveness.The claims that “we have many effective drugs to ease suffering ... we know the risks and benefits of taking them. That’s the beauty of our drug approval system ... ” fails to acknowledge that properly administered, FDA-approved prescription drugs kill over 100,000 people each year in the United States while there has never been a reported death from marijuana during its 5,000 years of medicinal use.People of Hawaii whose pain and nausea can be relieved by marijuana cannot wait to join nonexistent clinical trials. They need relief as well as protection now.According to a recent poll, 77 percent of registered voters in Hawaii support the proposed medical marijuana bill.Hopefully, our legislators have the compassion and courage to pass the bill now before them.William B. Wenner, M.D.Volcano, Big IslandMedical Marijuana Has Too Many Drawbacks:Medical marijuana is a bad idea for the community, and policing the proposed bill would be problematic for law enforcement.Initially, most people feel that it is the “compassionate” thing to do — to legalize its use for patients with chronic medical conditions. It certainly is not the responsible thing to do.Circumventing the regulatory process that all other “medicines” go through is unwise and unsafe. Many patients with chronic, debilitating medical conditions are already using numerous medications, and the drug interactions are uncertain with marijuana.Marijuana is not a benign substance. It is the fourth most frequently abused drug for which treatment is sought (following alcohol, methamphetamine and cocaine). It is the No. 1 primary drug of abuse for which adolescents sought treatment (1999 Data from the Alcohol and Drug Abuse Division, Department of Health). Over 25 percent of the ADA-funded client admissions were admitted with marijuana as the primary substance of abuse.The Senate bill allows for an adequate supply of up to 10.5 ounces, which equates to nearly 500 marijuana cigarettes. This is excessive and unreasonable.There’s no mention of how we are going to control quality and quantity, which is very important for a medicine.“Medical use” as defined in Senate Bill 862, SD 2 and House Bill 1157, HD 2 has within the definition the words “cultivation, distribution, transportation.” There are no requirements for licensing or registration for this group of “medical users.” So, reading between the lines, this essentially legalizes anyone to grow marijuana since there is no registry or control over this group. We strongly oppose the allowance of uncontrolled marijuana cultivation. Diversion into the illicit drug market is certain with these bills.The primary caregiver (supposedly providing marijuana or assisting in its use) is not required to register in any manner, thereby making it difficult, if not impossible, for law enforcement to verify any “medical use” without inordinate delays.I believe the bills were intended to be compassionate, but medical experts have stated that we already have as good and better pain-management medications on the market.For people who feel that marijuana is still the best medicine, the federal government continues to research the feasibility of marijuana as medicine. Alternative delivery systems such as skin patches and inhalers are being explored. Let’s do the responsible thing and be patient for further study.The appropriate forum for possible medical use is the laboratory, not the Legislature. Irresponsible “medical marijuana” legalization is a poor idea for our community.Maj. Susan DowsettNarcotics/Vice DivisionHonolulu Police DepartmentPosted on: Sunday, March 19, 2000 © COPYRIGHT 2000 The Honolulu Advertiser, a division of Gannett Co. Inc.Related Articles:Legislators Approve Marijuana Proposals http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread5006.shtmlMedical Marijuana Bills Making Progress http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread4969.shtmlHawaii Congresswoman Supports MMJ Researchhttp://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread1880.shtmlCannabisNews Medical Marijuana Archives:http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/list/medical.shtml
Home Comment Email Register Recent Comments Help




Comment #3 posted by Kanabys on March 21, 2000 at 10:01:50 PT
BE PATIENT?????
What the hell does she (Maj. Susan Dowsett) mean 'be patient'?? Does she have AIDS, or Cancer or the myriad of other maladies of which Cannabis helps to allieviate symptoms? I'll bet not. It's easy to say 'be patient' when you're healthy, isn't it?
[ Post Comment ]

Comment #2 posted by D. Stanford on March 20, 2000 at 10:36:52 PT
FOLLOW HOLLAND!!!
All the arguements of this article can be resolved if they would bother to look at Holland's statistics. The percentage of teens there smoke LESS than here in the U.S.There's quality control in Holland, too. Just look at the successful countries to see what they're doing and stop blowing smoke in the wind. (Pun intended).
[ Post Comment ]

Comment #1 posted by researcher on March 19, 2000 at 23:09:22 PT
It's BULL !!!
I can't stand reading such tripe. The writer puts forth a terribly illogical story.They want to RESEARCH it before approval? Five thousand years of research isn't enough? And what about the teens that seek help for marijuna addiction? Are these the kids that were caught with pot and forced to take a course andwatch a film called Reefer Madness?
[ Post Comment ]

Post Comment


Name: Optional Password: 
E-Mail: 
Subject: 
Comment: [Please refrain from using profanity in your message]
Link URL: 
Link Title: