cannabisnews.com: Jury Finds Man Using Med. Marijuana Defense Guilty





Jury Finds Man Using Med. Marijuana Defense Guilty
Posted by FoM on July 29, 1999 at 15:43:05 PT
By David Royse, Associated Press Writer 
Source: Miami Herald
BRONSON, Fla. -- (AP) -- A jury Thursday rejected a man's claim that he needs marijuana to cope with the side effects of potent painkillers and convicted him on marijuana possession charges.
Joe Tacl, 46, acknowledged smoking marijuana. But his lawyers argued the prohibition against the drug in this case should be ignored. Marijuana was the only thing he found that eased the nausea caused by painkillers he took for his severely damaged back.On his way out to the courtroom Tacl said he wanted to leave the country.``I'm not going to live in Nazi Germany,'' he said. ``I'm very angry.''In their closing argument to jurors, prosecutors Tim Browning and John Wentzlaff argued that regardless of Tacl's pain, the law was broken.``If you let sympathy cloud your common sense and if you let sympathy sway you away from a lawful verdict, then justice will have been left on the floor of the jury room,'' Browning said.The case was one of the first to go to a jury in a felony marijuana possession case in Florida since the state Supreme Court in June effectively said defendants were free to use the medical necessity defense for marijuana possession.The jury took less than two hours to find Tacl and his 20-year-old son, Michael, guilty of growing marijuana on their property, having the drug in their possession at their house and misdemeanor charges of possessing drug paraphernalia.Sentencing for both was set for Sept. 1. Defense attorney Gary Wainwright said the case will be appealed.Tacl lives with his wife, Anne, and his son in this rural area west of Gainesville.The prosecution said Tacl didn't exhaust every legal possibility to try to ease his pain and nausea before deciding on marijuana, citing several legal drugs that he had never taken.Prosecutors didn't produce any expert witnesses to testify that medical use of marijuana for Tacl's symptoms is not legitimate. ``I guess they couldn't find one,'' Wainwright said.Tacl's doctor had testified that he has had to take powerful painkillers, including methadone, morphine, and fentinil -- a narcotic so potent it can only be delivered through a patch on the skin in small doses.Tacl claimed he had near-constant back pain since being run over by a van six years ago. He had back surgery that left him with four 8-inch titanium rods in his back, held there by metal screws.A pharmacologist testified during the trial that scientific tests have shown that claims of marijuana easing nausea were valid. He also testified that marijuana was relatively harmless -- at least compared to the legal prescription painkillers Tacl was taking.Michael Tacl was not allowed to use the medical need defense. His attorneys argued that the state didn't prove that the son ever smoked pot or that any of it was his.But Wainwright attacked a system in which family members might be prosecuted along with medical marijuana users because they live in the same house.Wainwright said that police were using that as a tactic, saying to medical marijuana users, ``If you can get off, we're going to get your family.''Six states allow marijuana possession for certain people who can document a medical need.Florida isn't one of them, although supporters of the idea are collecting signatures to get the issue on the 2000 ballot.The drug is still illegal under federal law, so even in the six states allowing medical marijuana people could face federal prosecution.The trial drew the attention of several activists who favor legalization of marijuana for medical purposes. Many attended the trial, while others camped on the courthouse lawn and offered literature about medical marijuana to passersby.During closing arguments, Browning urged jurors to focus on the alleged crime at hand.``Despite the appearances, this is a jury trial,'' Browning said. ``It is not a political platform for the legalization of marijuana.... A criminal trial is not a soapbox to espouse a political or social agenda.Pubdate: July 29, 1999Copyright 1999 Miami Heraldhttp://www.herald.com/content/today/digdocs/055863.htm Doctor Testifies On Man's Medical Need for Marijuana-7/29http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread2265.shtml
END SNIP -->
Snipped
Home Comment Email Register Recent Comments Help




Comment #1 posted by Anne Tacl on October 08, 2000 at 17:10:11 PT:
Tacl files ADA suit 
The Tacl's have filed a ADA lawsuit and filed a suit against the Sheriff and the Deputy who stole the TAcl's coin collection. Press releases to follow.
[ Post Comment ]

Post Comment


Name: Optional Password: 
E-Mail: 
Subject: 
Comment: [Please refrain from using profanity in your message]
Link URL: 
Link Title: