cannabisnews.com: Defense Tries Medical-Need Claim for MJ Possession





Defense Tries Medical-Need Claim for MJ Possession
Posted by FoM on July 28, 1999 at 11:01:55 PT
By David Royse, Associated Press 
Source: Naples Daily News
BRONSON - Holding up pill bottles and reading the labels, a lawyer for a man facing a marijuana charge told jurors Tuesday his client needs pot to fend off nausea caused by prescription drugs, including morphine, codeine and methadone.
Joe Tacl is on trial for growing marijuana. But he claims he needs it to help his digestive system tolerate the massive doses of painkillers he has had to take since his back was ruined when he was run over by a van six years ago. Noting opponents of marijuana use say it leads to harder drugs, defense attorney Gary Wainwright told jurors this case is the opposite. "Harder drugs led this man to marijuana," Wainwright said during opening statements at Tacl's trial in Levy County, a rural area west of Gainesville. "What this case is about is basically a human being's right to have health," Wainwright said. The pill bottles were only one visual element to a trial that supporters of medical marijuana and some advocates for the disabled cite as a test case for a medical-need defense to marijuana possession. Tacl, 46, has sat through most of the trial, in its second day after a day of jury selection, in a wheelchair. But he has also occasionally had to retire to a futon bed on the floor or to a hospital bed near the defense table. Tacl's 20-year-old son Michael is also on trial. The two are accused of growing five marijuana plants, having more than 40 grams of the drug in their house when they were arrested last year, and having several items of drug paraphernalia such as pipes and grow lights, said prosecutor John Wentzlaff. The case has also drawn a few demonstrators to the front lawn of the courthouse. And the beginning of testimony was delayed as the judge heard from a Fort Lauderdale advocate for the disabled whose service dog, Red Zeppelin, was being denied access to the courtroom. Circuit Judge Frederick Smith let the man, Frederick A. Shotz, bring his reddish Doberman pinscher in after Shotz told him the dog, which pulls his wheelchair, goes everywhere with him "from symphony concerts to baseball games" and that to deny the dog access was to deny Shotz access. Smith also had to contend with a heavy media presence, including cameras from Court TV and area television crews, as well as a man with a video camera making a documentary. The first witness, a Levy County sheriff's deputy, testified he and his partner originally spotted the marijuana while returning by helicopter from another drug operation. Other deputies testified that when officers returned to the home at a later date, Tacl and his son told them the marijuana was theirs. Wainwright told jurors Tacl has a Dutch prescription for marijuana, and showed it to deputies. Marijuana is legal in the Netherlands. A recent decision by the state Supreme Court effectively gave the OK to people charged with marijuana possession to try to convince jurors they need pot for their pain. Tacl, who took several pills during the trial, had to be reminded several times by the judge not to respond aloud to testimony. At one point, Tacl blurted out "he's lying," during a deputy's testimony. Prosecutor Tim Browning asked for a mistrial but Tacl's attorney argued his client may be hurting his case, more than helping it, in the eyes of the jury. The judge declined to grant the mistrial. Tacl, a former car salesman, is one of the first to go before a jury in a major marijuana possession case to ask a jury to buy the defense. His lawyers told jurors he has four 8-inch titanium rods and several metal screws in his back. The painkillers he takes, including one so powerful it has to be administered through a patch to control its dosage, have often left him unable to keep food down. Six states have laws allowing the use of marijuana under limited circumstances for medical reasons. Florida isn't one of them. Here, possession of large amounts is a felony, as is growing it. If Tacl or his son are convicted, each could face up to 11 years in prison, although as first time felons they would be likely to receive a much lighter sentence. http://www.naplesnews.com/today/florida/d251817a.htmPubdate: July 28, 1999Entire contents © 1999 Naples Daily News.All rights reserved.Published in Naples, Florida.A Scripps Howard newspaper.'Medicinal Marijuana' Trial To Begin - 7/27/99http://www.cannabisnews.com/news/thread2230.shtml
END SNIP -->
Snipped
Home Comment Email Register Recent Comments Help




Post Comment


Name: Optional Password: 
E-Mail: 
Subject: 
Comment: [Please refrain from using profanity in your message]
Link URL: 
Link Title: